As we’ve been discussing the past few weeks, the sudden fear in the spring of 1798 that the US would soon be at war with its former ally, France, led many to panic across the country. The Federalists used the crisis to push through a barrage of legislation, authorizing a large standing army, building a navy, and going after immigrants. One of the most controversial actions taken all summer was the Sedition Act.
All of these acts were debated during the spring and summer of 1798. The Sedition Act was the last, passed just before Congress ended its session and got out of town as another yellow fever epidemic spread through Philadelphia.
Passing the Act
The House of Representatives had initially proposed a combined Alien and sedition bill, which got broken up in committee. Congress dealt with the Alien bill, which morphed into both what we later dubbed the Alien Friends Act and the Alien Enemies Act, as well as changes to the Naturalization laws. We discussed all this last week.
![]() |
| The Sedition Act |
Even Alexander Hamilton was shocked by the bill. In a short note to Treasury Secretary Oliver Wolcott just after the bill was introduced, Hamilton characterized the bill as something that “may endanger civil War” and added “Let us not establish Tyranny.”
Vice President Thomas Jefferson, who had been presiding over the Senate, left town the day after the bill’s introduction. He wanted nothing to do with it.
Senators began making changes. They removed the designation of France as an enemy, the characterization of the actions as treason, and the imposition of the death penalty. They turned into more of a sedition bill than a bill that focused on the immediate desire to go after supporters of France in America.
The amended bill retained a provision that made it a crime to say anything “tending to justify the hostile conduct of the French Government toward the United States.” There were also more general criminal sanctions aimed at anyone who wrote, printed, published, or spoke any “libelous or scandalous” statement which might defame or weaken the government by harming the public reputation of the president, congress, or federal judges. The senators saw no irony in criminalizing any publications or utterances that might lead the public to believe that the Congress was “hostile to the constitution, or the liberties and happiness of the people.”
Any act of sedition could be punished by a fine of up to $2000 and imprisonment up to two years. Conspiracies to further such efforts could be punished by up to $5000 and five years’ imprisonment.
The Senate continued its work on the bill. Working through Independence Day, it passed its final bill on July 4th.
The House of Representatives then began making changes to the Senate bill. The House had much more Democratic Republican support and many more moderate Federalists. These forces softened the bill, but did not see any realistic chance of killing it entirely.
One big change was to allow truth as a defense. Under English common law at the time, harming the reputation of a leader was considered criminal libel, even if the harm was caused by revealing truthful information. The House bill made clear that libel would not apply to the revelation of truth. It could, however, apply to expressions of a personal opinion.
The House also introduced a provision that allowed juries, not only to decide whether the words were said or published, but also whether those words were, in fact, seditious. Under the Senate bill, a judge would make that determination. Given that most judges were Federalists, this would give defendants more of an opportunity to prevail. The House bill also required that the defendants be guilty of malice and expressing their words with the intent to bring government officials into disrepute. It was not enough simply to show that the damage to reputation happened.
Perhaps most importantly, the House added a sunset clause. The law would expire on March 3, 1801. That was the day that the next president would take office. Federalists agreed to this since they certainly would not want the other party retaking the presidency and using this power against them.
Notably, neither the Senate nor the House version included penalties for criticism of the Vice President. Since Jefferson held that job, the Federalists seemed fine leaving criticism against him to be acceptable under the law.
Following about a week of debate and amendments, the House narrowly passed the Sedition Act by a vote of 44 to 41 on July 10. The Senate approved the changes and President Adams signed the bill into law on July 14.
Free Speech Implications
Now you may be asking yourself, how could Congress pass this law and still support the First Amendment, regarding the freedom of speech and freedom of the press? In fact, one amendment offered during the House debate said, "nothing shall be construed, or extended to abridge the freedom of speech, or of the press... as secured by the constitution." This amendment was ultimately withdrawn without a vote, but it shows that the concern was on legislator’s minds.
The reasoning at the time was that many people, particularly among the Federalists, argued that free speech and free press rules in the First Amendment only applied to prior restraint. That is, the government could not prevent a private actor from speaking or publishing controversial material. It could, however, punish that person after the fact for whatever ideas he had expressed.
Britain, at one time, had boards of censors. Publishers were literally not permitted to publish anything without a government license. If you published things the government did not like, you could lose your license and not be permitted to publish anything else. Britain did away with that practice in 1695. Federalists in America believed that the First Amendment was simply designed to protect the established principle that the government could not try to license or otherwise prohibit publications in the first place. They did not believe that the Constitution protected speech and press from punishment after the public received those ideas or opinions.
The justification for this law was not simply that political leaders were personally offended by the attacks from the press and the public, although they were. Their reasoning was that such attacks undermined the public confidence in government and would lead directly to violence and possibly efforts to overthrow the government.
The Sedition Act was the first effort to codify this into federal law, but prosecutors had gone after publishers even before the Sedition Act was passed. Sedition was a common law offense in Britain. American jurists held that these common law principles applied in the US.
Pre-Sedition Act Indictments
There was only one indictment for sedition during the Washington Administration in 1795. A New York editor Thomas Greenleaf made remarks critical of the British Minister to the US during the height of the debates over the Jay Treaty. Prosecutors dropped that case, but when Greenleaf continued to publish such comments after the Adams Administration began, prosecutors indicted him again in 1797. This time, he was convicted and fined $700. Another prosecution around the same time targeted William Cobbett, a federalist editor. Cobbett was charged with libeling the Spanish Minister, but a New England grand jury refused to indict.
In 1798, just weeks before passage of the Sedition Act, federal marshals, once again acting under common law, arrested Benjamin Franklin Bache of the Philadelphia Aurora for libeling the president. Bache had been a constant thorn in the side of Presidents Washington and Adams. Before his case could go to trial, Bache died in jail during the yellow fever epidemic that hit Philadelphia.
A short time after Bache’s arrest, just eight days before passage of the Sedition Act, John Daily Burk and James Smith were indicted for libelling the president and Secretary of State Pickering. Both men would later be re-indicted under the Sedition Act. Pickering also ordered the arrest of another publisher, William Durell for reprinting an article critical of President Adams. He was arrested three days after the passage of the Sedition Act, but before prosecutors in New York had received word of its passage.
Prosecutions
Unlike the Alien Act that we discussed last week, which did not result in any actual victims during the Adams administration, the government started using the Sedition Act as a basis for prosecutions of a wide variety of cases.
One of the first targets was Congressman Matthew Lyon of Vermont. We discussed Lyon a few weeks ago, when the Democratic-Republican member spat in the face of Federalist Congressman Roger Griswold of Connecticut, resulting in Griswold attacking him with a wooden cane on the House floor a few weeks later.
Lyon began his own newspaper in 1798, while also serving in Congress. In it, he published an editorial which said that President Adams had an "unbounded thirst for ridiculous pomp, foolish adulation, and selfish avarice." It also criticized the president for using religion to promote hatred and persecution, and justifying war against France.
Government prosecution was fast and furious. Days after he published his editorial, Lyon was indicted on October 5, arrested on the 6th, tried on the 8th, and sentenced on October 9th to four months in prison and $1000 fine. This meant he was in prison during the mid-term elections that took place in November. Even so, his constituents reelected him and he returned to Congress, with him returning to Congress after finishing his sentence. He then published an article protesting his mistreatment by the federal marshal while in custody. Prosecutors used this to indict him again in 1799. This indictment ran into more trouble since the sedition act said nothing about criticizing a federal marshal. Lyon also avoided arrest by traveling to Congress. The Constitution says that no member of Congress may be detained on his way to or from Congress.
Regular Americans were also subject to the Sedition Act. The same week officials indicted Lyon, President Adams was on his way home when he passed through New Jersey. It may be hard to believe today, but back in that time, people in New Jersey were not always respectful towards authority figures. In Newark, officials fired a ceremonial cannon in the president’s honor. Luther Baldwin drunkenly declared that he wished the cannon had struck the president in his backside, and Brown Clark drunkenly approved of the statement. Both men were arrested, and fined under the Sedition Act. At the same time Lespenard Colie of Springfield, New Jersey was heard saying “damn the president”. He was also arrested and fined.
In November, 1799, residents of Deham, Massachusetts erected a liberty pole with the sign that read: “No Stamp- Act, no Sedition, no Alien Bills, no Land-Tax; downfall to the Tyrants of America, peace and retirement to the President, long live the Vice- President and the Minority; may moral virtue be the basis of civil government."
Local federalists quickly cut down the pole. That could have been the end of it, but several months later prosecutors arrested Benjamin Fairbanks and David Brown for helping to erect the liberty pole. Fairbanks delivered an abject apology for his role in hopes of leniency. It worked. He received a sentence of only six hours in prison and a $5 fine. Brown also pleaded guilty but offered no apology. He received 18 months in prison and a $400 fine.
Prosecutions continued throughout the Adams Administration. After William Duane replaced Benjamin Franklin Bache as publisher of the Aurora, he was indicted at least four different times for articles that reported on, among other things, British bribery and influence of government officials. He managed to get each of the cases dismissed.
Jedidiah Peck, a New York State assemblyman circulated positions calling for the repeal of the Alien and Sedition Acts. For simply petitioning for the repeal, he was arrested. Prosecutors eventually dropped the charges after dealing with public outrage.
One female publisher, Ann Greenleaf was indicted for articles praising a liberty pole and criticizing the Sedition Act. Prosecutors agreed to dismiss the charges after she agreed to sell her paper and stop publishing anything.
Charles Holt of the New London Bee in Connecticut published an essay in 1799 criticizing the large standing army that the government was assembling. He was arrested, tried and convicted, sentenced to three months in prison and a $200 fine.
Anthony Haswell of Vermont received two months in prison and a $200 fine simply for reprinting one of the Aurora’s articles and also for carrying a lottery ad that Vermonter’s were running to pay Mathew Lyon’s fine under the Sedition Act.
Thomas Cooper of Pennsylvania circulated a handbill criticizing President Adams for the nation’s high interest rates. For this act of sedition, he received a sentence of six months in prison, a $400 fine, and had to put up a $2000 bond to ensure that he would express no more seditious language.
One of the last prosecutions in 1800 was James Callender, who I wrote about a few weeks ago. Callender had published the details of Alexander Hamilton’s affair with Maria Reynolds in 1797. That's not what got him in trouble. In 1800, he published a nearly 200 page book entitled The Prospect Before Us. It was highly critical of the Adams Administration. It also criticized Washington and Hamilton.
It included biting attacks on the president, famously calling Adams a “hideous hermaphroditical character” who lacked both manly force and feminine gentleness. It attacked him for promoting a war with France, for wasting tax dollars on large useless fleets and armies, for having monarchical tendencies, and for suppressing dissent under the Sedition Act.
The work was clearly written as a campaign peace, encouraging voters to use the 1800 elections to remove Adams and elect Jefferson. Callender told his readers “Take your choice, between Adams, war and beggary, and Jefferson, peace and competency.” In fact, Jefferson largely supported the publication financially, although that was not well known at the time..
Federal prosecutors showed no hesitation in going after Callender. The Prospect Before Us went on sale on May 2, 1800. Callender was arrested on May 27 and by June 4 was sentenced to nine months in prison and a $200 fine.
Administration Justifications
One could easily think that the Sedition Act was a calculated effort to stifle political dissent without any need to justify the use of the power. But Federalist leaders, including Adams itself, happily explained the principled need for such prosecutions.
Adams wrote privately at the time that he believed that public virtue had decayed and that the fate of the republic itself was threatened. He thought the political opposition was under the influence of a foreign power, France, and that they meant to overthrow the elected government. He also thought he had a duty to protect the government from libelous attacks.
In published responses at the time he argued that political attacks on the government led to "a spirit of party, which scruples not to go all lengths of profligacy, falsehood, and malignity, in defaming our government" He warned the public that unrestrained hostility against elected authorities would ultimately weaken the nation and leave it "ripe for a military despotism under the domination of a foreign power."
Even years later, reflecting back on the events, he justified his actions as a necessary war measure. He believed the French subversion of the country was real and that the actions to suppress opposition speech were justified.
His wife Abigail, also strongly supported the actions, writing in private letters in 1798 that she hoped Congress would pass the laws. She thought the criticisms of her husband were outrageous and would lead to more violence.
Others in the administration felt similarly. Secretary of State Pickering was responsible for instigating many of the prosecutions. Even those no longer in office, including Washington and Hamilton, supported the use of the Act. Washington had been particularly outraged by the attacks on his presidency by the press and seemed pleased that his successor was finally taking action in this matter.
The Federalist Press also supported the Act. Editor John Fenno wrote: “It is Patriotism to write in favour of our government—it is Sedition to write against it.” As I said, many believed that free speech only applied to prior restraint. Many did not seem terribly bothered by the notion of punishing critics after the fact simply for expressing their views on government policies.
Conclusion
This is not to say there wasn’t opposition. The Democratic-Republicans did believe that the Sedition Act violated basic principles of the freedoms of speech and press. We’ll get into that in an upcoming episode when we discuss the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions. The Sedition Act, however, remained in place until it expired at the end of Adams’ term in office and was largely used throughout his term.
The Act silenced some critics and even forced several newspapers to close. Many Americans silenced themselves or moderated their comments out of a fear of prosecution. Even Vice President Jefferson stopped writing about politics in private letters for fear that postal officials would read his mail and that it would lead to his prosecution.
At the same time public backlash was fierce. Many of those who were prosecuted became political martyrs whom the opposition held up as heroes to the cause of liberty. Having a government try to suppress political protests of the same sort that they had supported during the American Revolution led many Americans to equate President Adams with the hated King George III. In the end, the Sedition Act simply seemed unamerican, and ultimately contributed to the death of the Federalist Party.
Next Week: Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions
- - -
Next Episode 407 The Sedition Act of 1798 (coming soon)
Previous Episode 405 The Quasi-War Navy
![]() |
| Click here to donate |
![]() |
| Click here to see my Patreon Page |
Signup for the AmRev Podcast Mail List
Further Reading
Websites
An Act in Addition to the Act, Entitled "An Act for the Punishment of Certain Crimes Against the United States https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/sedact.asp
Sedition Act of 1798 https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/law/sedition-act-1798
Senate proposed bill: https://www.loc.gov/item/rbpe.22400700
“Alexander Hamilton to Oliver Wolcott, Junior, [29 June 1798],” Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-21-02-0296
Aitken, Robert, and Marilyn “The 1798 Sedition Act: President’s Party Prosecutes Press.” Litigation, vol. 33, no. 4, 2007, pp. 53–57. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/29760659
BIRD, WENDELL. “New Light on the Sedition Act of 1798: The Missing Half of the Prosecutions.” Law and History Review, vol. 34, no. 3, 2016, pp. 541–614. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/24771428
Farber, Alan J. “Reflections on the Sedition Act of 1798.” American Bar Association Journal, vol. 62, no. 3, 1976, pp. 324–28. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/25727556
Jenkins, David. “The Sedition Act of 1798 and the Incorporation of Seditious Libel into First Amendment Jurisprudence.” The American Journal of Legal History, vol. 45, no. 2, 2001, pp. 154–213. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/3185366
Moore, Wayne D. “Taking a Stand for Speech.” OAH Magazine of History, vol. 9, no. 2, 1995, pp. 19–25. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/25163010
Free eBooks
(from archive.org unless noted)
Adams, Charles F. The Life of John Adams, Vol. 2, Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott & Co. 1871.
Bowers, Claude G. Jefferson and Hamilton: The Struggle for Democracy in America, London: Constable and Co. 1925.
Callender, James The Prospect Before Us, Richmond: Printed by the Author, 1800.
Lawson, Elizabeth The Reign of Witches: The Struggle Against the Alien and Sedition Laws, New York: Civil Rights Congress, 1952.
Miller, John C. Crisis in Freedom: The Alien and Sedition Acts, Atlantic-Little Brown Books, 1951.
Morse, Jr. John T. John Adams, Boston: Houghton, Mifflin and Co. 1884.
Otis, Harrison Gray Mr. Otis's speech in Congress, on the Sedition Law, 1818.
Smith, James Morton Freedom’s Fetters: the Alien and Sedition Laws and American Civil Liberties, Cornell Univ. Press, 1956 (borrow only).
Wood, John The History of the Administration of John Adams, Esq., Late President of the United States, New York: Barlas and Ward, 1802.
Books Worth Buying
(links to Amazon.com unless otherwise noted)*
Benner, David Compact of the Republic, Life & Liberty Publishing Group, 2014.
Berkin, Carol A Sovereign People: The Crises of the 1790s and the Birth of American Nationalism, Basic Books, 2017.
Bird, Wendell Criminal Dissent: Prosecutions under the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798, Harvard Univ. Press, 2020.
Brown, Ralph A. The Presidency of John Adams, Univ. of Kansas Press, 1975.
Chernow, Ron Alexander Hamilton, Penguin Press, 2004.
Chervinsky, Lindsay M. Making the Presidency John Adams and the Precedents That Forged the Republic, Oxford Univ. Press, 2024.
DeConde, Alexander The Quasi War: The Politics and Diplomacy of the Undeclared war with France, 1797-1801, Charles Scribner's Sons, 1966 (borrow on archive.org).
Elkins, Stanley M. and Eric McKitrick, The Age of Federalism: The Early American Republic, 1788–1800, Oxford Univ. Press, 1993 (borrow on archive.org).
Kurtz, Stephen G. The Presidency of John Adams: The Collapse of Federalism, 1795-1800, Literary Licensing, LLC, 2011.
Malone, Dumas Jefferson and the Ordeal of Liberty, Little Brown & Co. 1962 (borrow on archive.org).
Stinchcombe, William The XYZ Affair, Praeger, 1980.
Stone, Geoffrey R. Perilous Times: Free Speech in Wartime: From the Sedition Act of 1798 to the War on Terrorism, W.W. Norton, 2005 (borrow on archive.org).
Wood, Gordon S. Empire of Liberty: A History of the Early Republic, 1789-1815, Oxford Univ. Press, 2009.
Young, Alfred, Garry Nash and Ray Raphael (eds) Revolutionary Founders: Rebels, Radicals, and Reformers in the Making of the Nation, Knopf, 2011.
Halperin, Terri D. The Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798: Testing the Constitution, Johns Hopkins Univ. Press 2016 (borrow on archive.org).
Hoffer, Peter C. The Free Press Crisis of 1800: Thomas Cooper's Trial for Seditious Libel, Univ. Press of Kansas, 2011.
McCullough, David John Adams, Simon & Schuster, 2001.
Meacham, Jon Thomas Jefferson: The Art of Power, Random House, 2012
Miller, John C. Alexander Hamilton and the Growth of the New Nation (or Portrait in Paradox), Harper & Brothers, 1959 (borrow on archive.org)
Nester, William The Hamiltonian Vision, 1789-1800, Potomac Books, 2012.
Phalen, William J. The First War of United States: The Quasi War with France 1798-1801, Vij Books India, 2018.
Randall, Willard Sterne Thomas Jefferson: A Life, Henry Holt and Co. 1993.
Shaw Peter The Character of John Adams, Univ. of NC Press, 1976.
Slack, Charles Liberty's First Crisis: Adams, Jefferson, and the Misfits Who Saved Free Speech, Grove Atlantic, Inc. 2015.
Smith, Jean E. John Marshall: Definer of a Nation, Henry Holt & Co. 1996.
Staloff, Darren Hamilton, Adams, Jefferson: The Politics of Enlightenment and the American Founding, Hill and Wang, 2005.
* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.




